Mini-Rumble provide feedback

[colls]

Please provide feedback for the the following icons. You do not need to be a participant in the rumble to provide feedback (the more the merrier). Please provide at least 2 positive and 1 constructive criticism - more if you'd like, additional feedback is welcome.

Feedback should be based on the technical and aesthetic aspects of the icon, not the subject/fandom or icon maker (if you know or suspect who it is). For more details on how to provide constructive feedback, please see this post: How To: A Constructive Criticism Voting Deconstruction.
ETA: some add'l examples for those interested are A Good Concrit Vote Showcase (thank you, tinny for the link)

Some examples of feedback (positive and constructive) are:
- I love the intensity of the colors, as well as the use of textures
- Good contrast and balance of dark and light with the textured background
- even though the background has been used greatly, not much has been done to the subject matter, perhaps a bit more brigthness would have worked better
- texture could be lightened to blend better with XYZ

Feedback will be screened on this post and will remain anonymous. I will compile a list of positive feedback for the icon makers in a wrap-up post. Icon makers can then respond to that post if they'd like me to pass along and constructive feedback (if applicable).

Please use the questions thread below if you have any questions. And thank you in advance for your feedback!
ETA: Please provide feedback by May 24.

( icons - NEGATIVE SPACE )

( icons - CLOSE CROP )

FEEDBACK TEMPLATE:
<B>Positive</b> icon #, <B>Positive</b> icon #, <B>Constructive:</b> icon #, (optional) <B>Additional feedback</b> icon #,